Inspectors/Kirkaldy J
Inspector: Kirkaldy J
Appeal outcomes for this inspector over the last 12 months
All appeals · last 12 months
Allowed rate 62%, up 41.7 pp vs the previous 12 months, with 1100% more decisions.
Allowed rate
62%
+41.7 pp (20% → 62%)
Appellant success
Decided
60
+1100% (5 → 60)
vs previous 12 months
Allowed · dismissed
37 · 23
Outcomes in the rate (other results excluded)
Allowed rate is allowed ÷ (allowed + dismissed). Part-allowed and other successful appellant outcomes count as allowed. Withdrawn, lapsed, invalid, turned away, and unknown outcomes are excluded from the rate but included in decided counts. Linked child cases are excluded.
Latest outcomes
Five most recent decisions. Open a case for the full decision record.
| Reference | Date | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 6008477 | 31 Jul 2026 | Allowed |
| 6009110 | 31 Jul 2026 | Dismissed |
| 6007644 | 31 Jul 2026 | Dismissed |
| 6007895 | 29 Jul 2026 | Dismissed |
| 3376538 | 28 Jul 2026 | Allowed |